This fall, two one-bedroom co-ops on Garth Road were listed $5,000 apart. A 750-square-foot unit at 260 Garth Road in Garth Essex was listed at $220,000 with $716 a month in maintenance before the STAR credit. An 850-square-foot unit at 143 Garth Road in The Colchester was listed at $225,000 with $1,236 a month. The difference in monthly charges is $520, or $6,240 a year. Over five years that adds up to $31,200, more than six times the gap between the two asking prices.
That pair shows how Garth Road works. Asking prices for similar units fall within a fairly narrow range. Monthly maintenance does not, and it varies by building. A buyer who sorts the corridor by list price ends up with a different shortlist from one who sorts by what a unit costs to carry.
A Scarsdale Address on Eastchester Land
Every building here has a Scarsdale, NY 10583 mailing address. The land is in the Town of Eastchester. Robert L. Mawson's December 2025 history of the Garth Road neighborhood places it in unincorporated Eastchester. The Village of Scarsdale is its northern boundary, the Metro-North tracks run along the east side and the Bronx River Reservation borders the west. The municipal line runs through the shopping strip at the north end. Mawson lists 22-28 Garth Road and the Garth Gables block at 30-56 Garth Road on Scarsdale tax lots. From 60-68 Garth Road south, including the Northgate Retail Building, the old Scarsdale Theatre site and the Grayrock Garage, the parcels are in Eastchester.
The Eastchester address affects the monthly bill. The Town of Eastchester Assessor's Office estimates values for property within Town boundaries and keeps the assessment roll used to compute tax bills. The Town also handles parking. Its commuter parking page has a Grayrock lot application set aside for Garth Road residents, separate from its Scarsdale commuter-resident permit, and says municipal parking depends on availability. A current listing at 281 Garth Road mentions the chance to join Lake Isle Country Club, Eastchester's club with an 18-hole course, eight tennis courts and five pools.
Scarsdale is still close by. The Scarsdale Metro-North station is just past the north end of Garth Road. Mawson calls it the second-busiest station on the Harlem line and puts it 50 minutes from Grand Central. Scarsdale Wine Merchants is at 2 Depot Place beside the station, which Scarsdale10583 described in 2025 as walkable from the Garth Road apartments.
Thirteen Buildings, Forty Years Apart
Maintenance differs so much because Garth Road is a series of separate buildings, each with its own age, size and budget. Mawson counts 13 mid-rise buildings on a half-mile stretch, built between 1926 and 1966. The first group went up in the 1920s:
- Scarswold at 155 Garth Road, 1926, with 39 units
- Thornycroft at 209 Garth Road, 1927, with 92 units, designed by George F. Pelham Sr.
- Eton Hall at 127, 1928
- Cragswold at 187, 1928
- Northgate at 105, 1928
- Eton Lodge at 117, 1929
- Colchester Hall at 143, 1929
The Buckingham at 253 and the 304-unit Scarsdale Manor at 178-198 came in the late 1930s. After the war came the larger complexes, built with integrated parking: Garth Woods at 235 in 1948 with 258 units, The Kenilworth at 142 in 1950, Garth Manor at 281 in 1959 and Garth Essex at 230-280 in 1966 with 347 units.
The buildings began converting to cooperative ownership in the 1970s. Today, Mawson writes, only two buildings with 80 units in total remain rentals. That leaves eleven ownership buildings, each with its own board and budget. A unit in a 39-unit 1926 building and a unit in a 347-unit 1966 complex share a street, a station and a mailing address. Their monthly bills cover very different buildings.
This Fall's Listings, Side by Side
These are Garth Road co-ops on OneKey MLS between late July and mid-November 2026. Statuses change quickly, so treat this as a snapshot.
| Building | Address and unit | Size | Price | Monthly maintenance | Status, fall 2026 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Garth Essex | 250 Garth Rd #2E3 | 1 bed, 800 sq ft | $210,000 | $885 | Active, listed Sept. 9 |
| Garth Essex | 260 Garth Rd #1A5 | 1 bed, 750 sq ft | $220,000 | $716 before STAR credit | Active, listed Aug. 14 |
| The Colchester | 143 Garth Rd #5J | 1 bed, 850 sq ft | $225,000 | $1,236 | Active, listed June 2 |
| Scarsdale Manor | 180 Garth Rd #6G | 1 bed, 850 sq ft | Sold $231,000 | $1,042 | Sold July 29 |
| The Buckingham | 253 Garth Rd #2A | 1 bed, 950 sq ft | $258,000 | $1,095 | Pending Nov. 4 |
| The Kenilworth | 142 Garth Rd #2S | 1 bed, 750 sq ft | $285,000 | $923 | Pending Sept. 17 |
| Garth Manor | 281 Garth Rd #A6H | 2 bed, 1,100 sq ft | $350,000 | $1,512 | Active, listed Oct. 23 |
| Garth Woods | 235 Garth Rd #E1G | 2 bed, 1,300 sq ft | $425,000 | $1,634, utilities included | Pending Oct. 15 |
| Garth Woods | 235 Garth Rd #A5B | 2 bed, 1,100 sq ft | $455,000 | $1,457, utilities included | Active, listed June 4 |
| Scarsdale Manor | 178 Garth Rd #TL | 2 bed, 1,225 sq ft | $489,000 | $1,654, utilities included | Active, listed Sept. 25 |
The six one-bedrooms show the pattern. From the lowest to the highest, asking prices rose about 36 percent, from $210,000 to $285,000. Monthly maintenance rose about 73 percent, from $716 to $1,236. Unit size and the order of maintenance charges do not line up either. The most expensive one-bedroom, The Kenilworth's $285,000 unit at 142 Garth Road, carried the third-lowest maintenance at $923.
Compare that unit with The Colchester's at 143 Garth Road, directly across the price range. The Kenilworth unit costs $60,000 more up front and $313 less each month. At $3,756 a year, the lower maintenance takes about 16 years to make up the price difference, if both buildings' charges hold where they are. Whether that trade makes sense depends on how long the buyer plans to stay, and the maintenance figure answers more of that question than the list price does.
What the Monthly Figure Includes
Maintenance figures only compare cleanly when they cover the same things. Three of the two-bedrooms above, 178 Garth Road in Scarsdale Manor and both Garth Woods units at 235 Garth Road, state that maintenance includes all utilities. The Garth Woods listing for #A5B spells it out: electric, heat, hot water and cooking gas, all inside the $1,457. In Garth Essex, figures are quoted before the STAR credit. One pending unit at 230 Garth Road shows $1,050 in its listing highlights and $1,123.40 before the credit in its description.
The Garth Woods unit at $1,457 with every utility included can cost less to live in than a two-bedroom elsewhere on the street with a similar charge and separate utility bills. Before comparing two Garth Road buildings, line up what each monthly charge covers.
How Fast Units Went Under Contract This Fall
Across Westchester County, co-ops spent an average of 56 days on market in the third quarter of 2026, twice the 28 days for single-family homes, according to OneKey MLS's Q3 2026 county report. In that quarter the county co-op median was $250,000 and the single-family median was $1,189,000. Most of the Garth Road one-bedrooms above are listed close to that county co-op median.
Garth Road's fall results line up with the maintenance figures. The unit at 230 Garth Road went pending 25 days after listing. The Buckingham's unit at $1,095 a month took 33 days. The Kenilworth's unit at $923 took 41 days. Two units have been listed since early June. The Colchester's one-bedroom carries the highest maintenance of any one-bedroom on the list, at $1,236. The Garth Woods two-bedroom at $455,000 has the highest asking price per square foot among the two-bedrooms, about $414. The three one-bedrooms that went under contract this fall carry monthly charges between $923 and about $1,125.
A well-priced unit can also draw competition. A one-bedroom at 180 Garth Road in Scarsdale Manor, listed at $199,999 in late May, sold on July 29 for $231,000, or $272 a square foot, with $1,042 in monthly maintenance.
Terms That Change the Calculation
Each building's own terms also affect how much cash a buyer needs at the start. Most of the fall listings state a 20 percent minimum down payment. The two Garth Essex units at 230 and 260 Garth Road state 25 percent, which on a $220,000 unit means $11,000 more up front than 20 percent would. The listing for the Garth Manor two-bedroom at 281 Garth Road calls it a sponsor unit. It also lists no pets, free permit parking on Garth Road, Grayrock Road and the resident lot, and about a three-year wait for indoor parking. The Garth Essex listing at 260 describes a short wait for indoor parking. For dog owners, The Colchester's listing says it is the only Garth Road co-op that allows dogs, up to 30 pounds. That helps explain why a building with higher maintenance still has buyers.
The figures in this post are general information, not legal, tax or financial advice. Confirm current maintenance, down-payment rules and building policies for your own situation with the co-op, your attorney and your lender.
A Few Quick Answers
Is Garth Road in the Village of Scarsdale? The apartment buildings are in unincorporated Eastchester and have Scarsdale 10583 mailing addresses. The northernmost shop blocks, 22-56 Garth Road, are on Village of Scarsdale tax lots.
Are any Garth Road buildings rentals? Mawson's 2025 history counts two rental buildings with 80 units in total. The rest of the corridor is cooperative ownership.
Where else can I compare Westchester co-ops? Our Scarsdale neighborhood page and Eastchester page cover the areas around the corridor. Our New Rochelle co-op and condo guide covers a nearby market.
If you are weighing two Garth Road buildings, Jennifer Fischman is glad to talk through the monthly numbers with you before you make an offer. Schedule a free consultation.